Is Common Core a Good Thing?

    Posted on Friday, August 7, 2015 at 9:30 AM

    Posted by Mike McPartlin on Aug 7, 2015 9:30:00 AM

    Let me start by acknowledging that Bridgedale Academy does not subscribe to the Common Core standards now being taught by virtually all other Illinois schools. This of course reflects the fact that we utilize the academic curriculum of Hillsdale Academy, which itself does not subscribe to the Common Core standards.

    Common Core Academics BadSo just what is Common Core (“CC”) and what are these standards?

    In a nutshell, CC reflects an attempt to establish national education standards. It is based on a document that sought to create a common set of curriculum standards in English language arts and mathematics. Forty-five states and the District of Columbia adopted the CC standards. One state, MN, adopted the English language arts standards but rejected the math. Four states, Alaska, Texas, Virginia and Nebraska, rejected Common Core in its entirety.

    Proponents of CC point out that in today’s mobile society, the notion of having different educational standards in different states is unworkable and disadvantageous to students moving from school to school. They also argue that the US has lagged behind many industrialized nations in key academic areas (e.g. math and science), and CC was needed as a coherent national plan to improve our country’s standing in these subject areas. This second argument includes the notion that the US will be less able to compete in a global society if our education systems reflect a “patchwork of state standards.”

    Critics of CC claim it will be prohibitively expensive to implement (some opponents have disparagingly labeled it “ObamaCore”), that rather than pushing the states toward high standards it encourages a mediocre middle, that new databases being used will create privacy invasion issues, and that the creation of a “national” program to control education violates the 10th Amendment of the US Constitution (i.e. powers not delegated to the federal government are reserved to the states).

    But there may be an even more compelling argument against CC.

    Both the language arts and the math components of CC appear designed to train drones, worker bees. The math component was actually rejected by the only mathematician on the CC Validation Committee, and the language arts component chose substantially to do away with the study of certain classic literature in order to focus on how to read technical manuals.

    The CC’s mission statement reflects the notion that the outcome being pursued is to prepare young people “for success in college and careers,” i.e. so that American communities can “compete successfully in a global economy.” In other words, workforce training.

    Yet many believe flatly this should NOT be the sole purpose of education.

    One prominent education policy analyst put it this way: “In a self-governing nation we need citizens who can govern themselves. The ability to support oneself with meaningful work is an important part, but only a part, of self-government. When a nation expands workforce training so that it crowds out the other things that rightly belong in education, we end up turning out neither good workers nor good citizens.”

    For my money, the education of citizens capable of self-government should be THE purpose of education in the US, a notion the Common Core standards appear to be at odds with.

    Read our other Common Core blogs at:

    Common Core: Mental Junk Food? Part 1

    Common Core: Mental Junk Food? Part 2

    Common Core: Mental Junk Food? Part 3


    "At Bridgedale we are committed to the development of our young student-athletes, helping them to develop their physical and mental skills so they can perform at their best when it matters most, no matter the arena of life that challenges them. If you would like to learn more about Bridgedale Academy, please click the button below so we can schedule a time to chat."
                                                                                                               Mike McPartlin, Headmaster, Bridgedale Academy


    To learn more about Bridgedale Academy, please click the button below so we can schedule a time to chat.


    Talk to Headmaster


    Bridgedale Academy Classical Education

    Training Elite Student Athletes  


    Bridgedale Academy is now accepting transfer students for the 2019-20 school year 

    Bridgedale Academy is an all-boys school for athletes, a prep school for serious youth golfers and hockey players, offering grades 5 through 8 each school year. In addition to our winning combination of sports and academics, we focus on leadership training. We use a classical academic curriculum and our graduates go on to attend some of the most prestigious high schools in the country, including Lake Forest Academy, Culver Military Academy, Shattuck St. Mary’s, Northwood School, Benet Academy, Fenwick Prep, St. Ignatius Prep, Marmion Academy, Latin School and Providence Catholic. We pride ourselves on being the top youth hockey prep school in the nation and look forward to the same success in golf as we begin admitting golf athletes during the 2019-20 school year. Our hockey successes are many: Eighteen (18) of our former or current students have already received their NCAA Division 1 college hockey commitments, with many more sure to follow soon. Three (3) of our graduates competed for USA Hockey’s National Team Development Program. Two (2) now compete for the University of Notre Dame. One just signed his entry-level contract with the NHL New York Islanders. Several Bridgedale grads are now playing junior hockey, including in the USHL, the OHL and the NAHL.
    « Previous Post Honoring America's Founding Documents Next Post » Bridgedale 10th Grader Jacob Pivonka Commits to Notre Dame